Understanding a patient’s Ideas, Concerns, and Expectations (ICE) is an integral part of patient-centered care in Australian general practice. Whether in real consultations or CCE scenarios, ICE helps GPs effectively address patients’ perspectives, creating shared understanding and improving consultation outcomes.

Adopting ICE is not just about achieving high marks in CCEs but is also essential for real-world consultations. It strengthens communication, enhances treatment adherence, reduces unnecessary prescriptions, and ensures greater patient satisfaction. Resources from the GP Institute can further support GPs in mastering patient-centered communication, including ICE frameworks.

---

Breaking Down ICE

1. Ideas

Exploring a patient’s ideas involves understanding their baseline knowledge, thoughts, and beliefs about their condition. By discussing their understanding, you can clarify misconceptions, provide education, and build rapport.

Key Phrases for Exploring Ideas:

• “What thoughts have you had about this issue?”
• “What do you think might be causing these symptoms?”
• “Have you considered what could be happening here?”

Incorporating open-ended questions ensures patients feel heard and encourages them to share their perspective freely.

2. Concerns

Concerns focus on the patient’s fears and anxieties. These could be about the seriousness of their condition, its future implications, or how it impacts their quality of life.

Key Phrases for Addressing Concerns:

• “What worries you most about these symptoms?”
• “Are there specific concerns you’d like to discuss today?”
• “What’s your biggest worry about this right now?”

Addressing these concerns directly validates the patient’s feelings and builds trust.

3. Expectations

Understanding a patient’s expectations ensures alignment between their goals and the consultation’s outcomes. It also helps manage misunderstandings about diagnostic or treatment options.

Key Phrases for Exploring Expectations:

• “What were you hoping I could do for you today?”
• “What do you feel might help with this issue?”
• “What outcomes are you expecting from this consultation?”

Being transparent about what is feasible and guiding patients toward realistic goals helps avoid dissatisfaction.

---

ICE in Practice: Example Consultation

Scenario: A 52-year-old postman presents with progressively worsening knee pain.

• Ideas: “I think it might be arthritis. My mum needed a hip replacement due to joint pain, and she also struggled with movement in her hands.”
• Concerns: “I’m worried about work. I’m on my feet all day, and the pain is unbearable after a shift. I’m scared I might need time off or even a job change.”
• Expectations: “I’d like an X-ray to confirm what’s going on. Knowing the diagnosis would help me plan better.”

By integrating ICE, the GP can address the patient’s fears (impact on work) and expectations (diagnostic testing) while providing a more tailored and patient-centered consultation.

---

Integrating ICE into Australian GP Consultations

1. Natural Integration

ICE should not feel like a rigid checklist. Instead, it should flow naturally within the consultation. Actively listening and responding empathetically to the patient’s answers ensures their concerns are fully addressed. Avoid dismissing or skimming over their concerns to ensure a patient-centered approach.

2. Structured Approach

A structured consultation framework, like the Calgary-Cambridge Model, can help integrate ICE effectively. During the gathering information stage, use both open and closed questions to explore the patient’s symptoms and beliefs. This lays the foundation for a more collaborative and productive consultation.

3. OSCE Application

For medical students and registrars preparing for OSCEs, covering ICE is crucial. Most patient scripts and examiner checklists explicitly include ICE, and failing to address these areas can result in lost marks. Resources from the GP Institute, including simulated patient scenarios, can help refine this skill.

---

Why ICE Matters in Australian General Practice

In Australia’s multicultural healthcare setting, ICE is vital for understanding diverse patient perspectives and delivering culturally sensitive care. For instance:

• Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients: Understanding cultural beliefs about illness and treatment is essential for building trust.
• Migrants and refugees: Exploring ideas and concerns can help address health literacy gaps and reduce language barriers.
• Chronic condition management: Aligning expectations ensures patients engage with long-term treatment plans.

---

Tips for Effective ICE Integration

• Practice empathetic listening to avoid making ICE feel like a box-ticking exercise.
• Use the patient’s responses to tailor your clinical explanations and care plans.
• Regularly engage with resources like the GP Institute’s ICE communication guides, which offer practical tools and real-world case studies.

By embedding ICE into routine practice, Australian GPs can strengthen patient-centered care, improve health outcomes, and build lasting patient relationships.